Stuff I Wrote

10 Ways You’re Probably Screwing up Hip Extension

Forgive the click-baity title. But its true: You’re probably screwing up hip extension (and I’d wager in more than 10 ways).

It’s not an insult. Garbage hip extension is perfectly normal (trust me, I know). But that doesn’t make it ok to live with…

I’d like to use this blog post to help you reclaim your best hip extension ever. Even if that happens 5 years from now… Get cracking today.

To give you a movement orientation to hip extension, check out this short excerpt from week three of my workshop, Liberated Body. Follow along and see where your hip extension capabilities are at:

FYI my next Liberated Body workshop is coming up Feb 18th! If you liked this clip and found it useful, you’ll love the whole 4 week workshop. 

The 10 most common hip extension errors you might be making

As you followed along with the hip extension movement in the video, were you able to feel lengthening of your hip flexor muscles? Or did you just feel your lower back getting cranky? Or your calf burning? Or or nothing at all…?

Check if you doing/not doing any of the following:

  1. Not maintaining a supinated foot, Either by lifting your heel too high and losing forefoot contact on the 1st and 5th metatarsal heads, or rotating your leg internally, leaving you with a pronated foot.
  2. Not getting a flat surface at the front of your hip (if it feels more slanted, it’s not extending)
  3. Pelvis staying behind your head, instead of moving forward underneath it.
  4. Stance is too split apart, pelvis cannnot travel enough onto front foot, and you may end up over-moving from your spine instead.
  5. Back knee bends as you move your pelvis forward, which has the effect of flexing your hip instead of extending it.
  6. Pelvis starts and stays in anterior tilt, which will also cause that hip to stay flexed.
  7. Accessing hip extension with a massive glute contraction, which you shouldn’t need to do. This may indicate how much additional work it is for your body to get into hip extension.
  8. Leaning ribcage backwards causing a hyper extension in the lumbar spine (swaybacking it).
  9. Leaning torso forwards, thinking that you’re moving your pelvis forward.
  10. Assuming that just because your leg is behind you your hip is extended! 

And here’s the confusing part: Just becaues you feel a hip flexor “stretch” it doesn’t necessarily mean your hips are extending well.

But before we get to the nitty gritty technical details of how to get your hips extending like a boss, I’d like to tell you the story of my poor, abused, hips.

The story is called…

Why You Shouldn’t Stretch in Bed

In my less informed days, I remember a dance teacher telling us it was good to sit in the splits for 30 mins at a time. So I did that.

I think one teacher even said that if we were really serious, we’d sleep in the frog position at night. Which I obvisouldy tried, too.

Other silly things dance teachers have suggested include:

  • If you’re not in pain you’re not a real dancer.
  • Wearing padding in your pointe shoes makes you weak.
  • Never, ever, take time off or you’ll lose all your hard earned technique.
  • And, always stretch. Always. Stretch. ALWAYS the solution.

I could drop into a split cold. I thought it was a cool party trick. I did a ton of hip flexor stretching, and as such, I thought I had a PhD in hip mobility.

But my hips were still “tight” all the time. I had anterior hip pain. Stretching felt good in the moment, in a palliative way, but never seemed to get me any additional mobility or relieve my tightness.

So I just forced harder (remember, dance teacher said ALWAYS STRETCH and pain is good).

Looking back on my hip flexor stretching efforts, I had at least 10 different ways to make it feel like my hips were extending, all of which were clever ways to avoid moving my actual hips by moving every other part of my body instead. 

This is my go-to way to pretend to extend my hips: The Lean Back! aka spine smush

So instead of extending my hips better, I was just compressing my lumbar spine with more resolve than ever before (see above photo). This is a factor in why I had so many lower back injuries (along with trying to show off in yoga classes).

The moral of the story is that stretching more and stretching harder didn’t help improve my hip tightness or range of motion. Quite the opposite: It reinforced all the other non-hip-motion strategies I’d unconsiously found in a naive attempt to stretch my tight hip flexors.

Promise me you will learn from my mistakes?

If you are like me- hip extension challenged- I hope this blog post helps you to find your truest, cleanest hip extension. 

And guess what… It’s not all about stretching your hip flexors.  

What is hip extension? 

If you Google “hip extension”, this is the first image that pops up:

The 4 Best Hip Extension Exercises | Openfit
I’m jealous! Wish my hips could extend in this exercise….

More commonly appreciated in the guise of the all-mighty “hip flexor stretch”, hip extension is a joint motion that refers to the opening of the space at the front of the hip.

With each step we take our rear hip needs to extend well for efficient gait.

I can’t ever take for granted that all readers of this blog know what the hip is, or reference it in the same way. Not since I had a chat with a student who stated, “What are you talking about, Monika?? The hip IS the same thing as the pelvis.”

No it is not… 

The hip joint is the space between which the femur (leg bone), and the pelvis meet. 

Osteonecrosis of the Hip - OrthoInfo - AAOS
Two bones, one space.

The joke in my movement nerd fam is that the hip is actually nothing. As it is nothing, it does nothing.

The two bones- femur + pelvis- are the actual moving structures of the hip. How we name the motion of the hip is based on the relative motion of those two bones and the resultant change in space between them.

In hip extension, the bottom portion (foot end) of the femur moves behind (posterior to) the pelvis, with relatively little motion of the pelvis itself.

To name the bones’ motions, we could say the pelvis is doing a posterior tilt, and the femur is doing an anterior tilt, opening the space at the front of the hip.

A Monika Volkmar original

So just tucking under your pelvis, squeezing your glutes, or getting into a deep lunge with your leg way behind you are not sufficient criteria to create an actual extension of the hip. We need the articulating surfaces of the two bones to experience real motion between them.

It sounds simple enough in theory. But in practice, oh man is it ever easy to screw up.

This leads us to another important techincal detail…

What’s the difference between a “hip flexor stretch” and accessing hip extension? 

A hip flexor stretch is the lengthening of hip flexor muscles. 

Hip extension is the joint motion that should result in hip flexor length when done correctly.

The two sound similar, but have different intentions, teach the body different things, and have very different outcomes. 

The irony is that one can find a hip flexor stretch without actually moving the hip joint. But it doesn’t feel very good because it means that you are over-moving another part(s) of your body in an attempt to put length into those hip flexors! (ie everything desribed in my story at the beginning of this post)

For example, over-extending your lumbar spine, over tucking your pelvis, leaning your ribcage way back, splitting your legs really, really wide apart and squeezing your butt, or any of the 10 things I listed earlier.

Good hip extension allows the glut max to work and generate running power
I really like this image from physioworkshsv.com showing in B a clean hip extension, and in C and D, strategies involving a forward lean, and lumbar extension to extend the hip. Much better than my drawing.

Another piece of the irony is that our hips only have up to about 10 to 20 degrees of actual extension. Finding those elusive degrees isn’t about making the movement bigger, but making it more precise and accurate.

Size is not the problem 😉 Accuracy and specificity are.

Eccentric load vs. hip flexor stretching: What’s the diff?

Eccentric load (or eccentric muscle contraction) is when the two bones of a joint are moving away from each other, and the muscle that spans those two bones must contract in it’s lengthening state to decelerate them moving away from each other.

It's Eccentric! | Golf Performance Center
The most commonest, easily understandablest visual of an eccentric contraction happening at the bicep. As the weight lowers, the bicep is contracting to decelerate it (slow it down).

However, the force of the bones moving away is greater than the ability for the muscle to contract to pull them together. All the muscle can do is slow down how fast the bones are moving apart.

(This is why eccentric muscle training tends to cause a lot more DOMS than concentric contractions, FYI.)

So one could say that the ability for a muscle to load eccentrically ensures a certain feeling of safety for the body in motion, because it is preventing a joint from opening too far for comfort, into a potential danger zone.

Gait (walking) is a predominantly eccentric muscle experience- Muscles decelerating joint movement, then contracting back.

Most muscle strain injuries are a result of a muscle’s inability to load eccentrically in response the force of the movement being undertaken. In fact, that’s exactly how I strained my hamstring: Over-stretching forcefully while warming up for dance class. *POP* Careful with those splits, guys…

This is why in Anatomy in Motion we consider the ability for the body to experience eccentric tissue load with joint movement to be so crucial. Not as a “stretch”, but as an indicator of healthy management of joint motion and efficiency in gait.

Joints act, muscles react, and muscles lengthen before they contract.

With each step you take, joints move, muscles respond to decelerate movement, and then contract back to move the joint back in the opposite direction.

This is a very different intention for a muscle than what my dance teachers had in mind: Stretch it into submission.

In an eccentric load, we are asking the muscle to respond back with a contraction.

In a stretch, we are asking the muscle to do nothing.

This was one of my biggest paradigm shifts when I began my AiM studies: We are not simply stretching muscles to get more mobility or flexibility, but we are showing the body how to access a joint motion in it’s correct context in gait, which should result in the muscle experiencing an eccentric load.

We don’t just want to tug on a muscle and over-ride the stretch response, because the intention of the eccentric muscle action is to contract that muscle back again, not make it longer and stay there. 

An eccentric load is an educational experience for the body.

If we are trying to access hip extension in the context of gait, we want to feel the hip flexors under eccentric load- not static stretch- which should give them no option but to contract back from their most lengthened position.

And where do they contract to take the hip? Into hip flexion! 

So what are we trying to teach our body with an eccentric load of the hip flexors, by virtue of true hip extension? To flex the hip.

This answer adds even more irony: Practicing hip extension isn’t necessarily to give you more mobility, or longer hip flexors, but to show your body how to better flex your hips.

When does hip extension happen in gait?

Hip extension, as a position, is a snapshot in time of your leg behind your body.

But as a motion in gait, hip extension doesn’t start and end with your leg behind you with the hip already stretched open. Hip extension starts the milisecond after the hip is fully flexed.

Hip extension begins when your leg is in front of you, and continues building until it ends up behind you, the moment when your foot swings forward again.

Remember the rule: Muscles lengthen before they contract.

Just as hip flexion is reliant on hip extension to eccentrically load the hip flexors and contract the hip into flexion, hip extension is reliant on being able to flex the hip with the leg in front of you, eccentrically loading the hip extensors, which then receive the stimulus to contract and bring the hip into full extension. 

(sorry, that paragraph was hard on my brain, too…)

So paradoxically, if you only have time to do one exercise to help your hips extend better, I personally would choose to work on my access to hip flexion instead of taking them directly into extension.

How can you tell if you’re actually extending your hip?

Your muscles are the best indicator for actual joint motion. Can you feel the hip flexors loading/lengthening?

Remember Gary Ward’s other rule: Joints act, muscles react. 

You will feel a hip flexor “stretch” if the surfaces of the pelvis and femur are actually articulating against each other, generating length (eccentric load) in the tissues spanning that joint space. 

What muscles? Anything that crosses the front of the space between the pelvis and femur, aka the hip flexors:

  • Psoas major
  • Iliacus
  • Tensor fascia latae
  • Adductors pectineus, longus, brevis, and the anterior portion of magnus
  • Rectus femoris
  • Sartorius
List of flexors of the human body - Wikipedia

Here is an excellent video by Gary Ward, showing how the psoas, one of the most famous hip flexors, lengthens in three dimensions in gait to decelerate the forwards motion of the body through space.

Hip extension is just one dimension of the phases in which your leg is behind you in gait. Note how there are two other planes of motion to consider- Frontal and transverse plane, but that’s a topic for another time.

Also remember, hip extension STARTS from a flexed hip. What muscles do we consider to be the main extensors of the hip? Glutes and hamstrings. So we also want to be able to find eccentric load in those muscles to get our best hip extension.

I covered this in the November Movement Nerd Hangout: Wake Up Your Butt. It’s all about how to access hip flexion, which you now know is crucial for hip extension, too. Check out the full 60 minute session and technical write-up here. 

anatomy in motion
AKA load your glutes eccentrically and indirectly extend your hips better

Conclusions?

Clean, honest hip extension means the joint surfaces of the two bones- femur and pelvis- need to articulate with each other, not move as one clump.

A hip flexor stretch is not the same thing as accessing hip extension cleanly.

A hip flexor stretch is not the same thing as loading the hip flexors eccentrically.

Hip extension starts from the moment your hip finishes fully flexing, not as the snapshot of a stretched open hip. 

In gait, hip extension must happen within a set of parameters that include foot supination, knee extension, pelvis posterior tilt, and center of mass moving forwards through space.  Change one thing, and you change everything.

There are more than 10 ways to screw up hip extension, but if you remember one thing: Never assume that just because your leg is behind you your hip is extending.

That’s it for now! It always amazes me how much I can write about one thing… It’s not a talent, it’s a real problem.

Let me know what came up for you. How is your hip extension? Shoot me a message and let me know!

I hope this was interesting and useful for you, and aids you on your journey to inhabiting your body with more ease and joy 🙂

Why Isn’t My Core Getting Stronger? A Case for “Core Mobility”

December 18th was this month’s edition of the Movement Nerd Hangout: A free monthly session to welcome you into my wee community of self-professed movement detectives (aka movement nerds).

This month’s topic was Core Training From the Inside Out (part 1). I figured everyone’s thinking about their mid-section around this hedonic time of year, so yes I jumped on that marketing train. Sue me.

Over 100 lovely people signed up to explore some rather unconventional concepts and ways of experiencing their “core”, such as:

  • What is core mobility vs. core stability? (and why this may be the missing link to building a strong core)
  • How could ankle sprain rehab be considered “indirect” core training?
  • What’s your center of mass (CoM) awareness got to do with core training? And how is it more important than a “neutral” spine?
  • What the heck is “neutral spine” anyway? Should you work on it?
  • How does Gary Ward’s rule of motion: Muscles lengthen before they contract, come to life in a diaphragmatic breath, as it relates to training dem abz?
  • How does access to 3D spinal mobility actually improve core stability? 

And more…

In case you missed the live session, here’s the complete recording:

Carve yourself out an hour to hang out with me and dive into my first two pillars of core training. Let me know how it goes for you!

And now, here’s the session breakdown, if you just want to read some words, or don’t have time to participate right now.

Core intentions

Here is what I set out to cover in the session:

  • Understand what is “the core”? And identify the key anatomy.
  • Understand and explore my first 2 (of four) pillars (that I made up) of core training: 1) Diaphragmatic breathing at rest, and 2) Accessing 3D spinal motion.
  • Apply Gary Ward’s two rules of motion: 1 ) Joints act, muscles react, and 2) Muscles lengthen before they contract, to core training, in contrast to “core stability”

Whoah what? A core training session that’s NOT about creating stability and engaging your abs?? But isn’t the core supposed to be stable??

We’ll get right into that, but let’s first look at some of the key anatomy.

Core anatomy

What is the core, anyway?

In the session, I asked participants: “Point to your core”.

Do it now… What are you actually pointing to?

Are you pointing to muscles? Are you pointing to your ribcage? Are you pointing to your intra-abdominal pressure? Are you poining to your center of mass? Are you pointing to your breath?

The core is all of that, and more than all that. It is how all of that interacts.

The core is more than a set of muscles.

More than a label of weak or strong. More than something to squeeze, tighten, and brace. It’s more than stabilizing your spine. More than something to tone and make look good. And not something we need to dedicate a whole gym day to.

But I digress… Let’s take a look at the key muscles, bones, and joints of the core.

Key muscles & structures

Bones and joints:

  • Pelvis
  • Ribcage
  • Spine
Consider the muscles that attach from ribcage to pelvis, spanning the length of the spine

Muscles (that connect directly to those bones and joints)

  • Rectus abdominis
  • Internal obliques
  • External obliques
  • Transversus abdominis
  • Diaphragm
  • Multifidus and other inter-vertebral muscles

    *Note, however, we won’t be talking specifically about muscles today, because it’s actually not that useful experientially, and makes things way more complicated than necessary.
Voila les muscles.
Inhale and exhale your pain away: the diaphragm muscle and how it relates  to back pain! - Diversified Integrated Sports ClinicDiversified Integrated  Sports Clinic
And the diaphragm, attaching from ribcage to spine. Contracts with inhalation and relaxes wtih exhalation.

These structures and muscles all have a specific role in gait.

What does the core do while you’re walking?

WHEN does it contract? HOW does it contract? Should you even think about contracting it while you walk? (No…)

The abdominal muscles are no different than any other muscle in motion: They go through phases of loading/contraction, lengthening/shortening, as the joints they attach to go through phases of opening/closing, compression/decompression.

This all happens multiple times per foot step, in all three planes of motion.

While I don’t say it explicitly, day one of my Liberated Body workshop (spine mechanics day) could be considered a “core training” session, because it’s all about experiencing spine, pelvis, and ribcage movements as they occur harmoniously in gait.

Within the fraction of a second it takes for each foot step, all the structures of the core lengthen then contract, compress then decompress, in all three planes.

Gait might be the best core “workout” you can get 😉

So… Can you appreciate that core training is about more than just stability, six packs, and neutral spine?

“Direct” and “indirect” core training

This is something I made up, so take it with a grain of salt. But I’d love to hear if it resonates with you as a concept.

I’d like to poropose two types of “core training” (neither of which involves stability, or romanticizing neutral spine):

Direct (or local)

– Working directly with the spine and trunk musculature, the position/movement of spine, pelvis, and ribcage, and the ability to breathe within all options for those positions/movements.

– The potential for the structures named above to alternate between demands for movement or creating stiffness, in a way that is effective for the current task.

Examples of direct core training: Working directly on spine mobility. Doing core stability exercises, like deadbugs. In real life, being able to brace the abdominal muscles, create a rigid spine, and maintain intra-abdominal pressure in order to push your car uphill.

Indirect (or global)

– Freedom for one’s center of mass (CoM) to move freely within the base of support of your feet, to all it’s edges. The ability to find your best “center”, having explored those edges, instead of forcing an idea of neutral spine on a structure lacking awareness of center.

– CoM mobility (or “core mobility”, a term Gary Ward coined in What the Foot) gives rise to the core musculature (and all musculature) reflexively responding, unconsciously, as the body moves.

– Indirect training is specific to the individual based on their unique history- Injuries, sports, habitual patterning and postures. Indirect work is to give the whole body back “what’s missing”, knowing it will impact on how the core functions.

Example of indirect core training: I’ll use an example of one of my clients. I’ll call him Lars.

Lars had a left ankle sprain, and now he can’t bend that knee very deeply, and he can’t get his body (CoM) over to his left foot.

He looks a little like this:

Another Monika Volkmar original

Lars has left side SI joint and lower back pain, and does a ton of core stability training, because shouldn’t stronger abs help with your SIJ and back?

Not if the problem is that you can’t put weight on your left foot, which is the case for Lars. He can’t shift his center of mass left without weird compensations in his spine and pelvis.

All the blue shading is where muscles are getting pulled long, which are the areas he feels “tight”.

He is very good at training his abs in his off-center place- He’s got a very “strong” core. But it is not helping him to liberate his mass to move freely from one foot to the other, only serving to further lock him into an off-center structure.

As we’ve been working on his left ankle and knee, his pelvis and spine are balancing out, helping him to use his abs better, from a more centered place, because he doesn’t need to lean away from his left leg so much.

So yes, core training is absolutely about the spine, and muscles (direct).

And its also about the whole body’s ability to move freely, not avoid motions that feel unsafe due to past injuries, accidents, or trained movement patterns.

Lars’ ankle and knee movement training was indirectly giving him better access to his core, as he began to inhabit a more centered structure.

Ok now finally onto pillar #1…

Core Training Pillar #1: Diaphragmatic breathing at rest

This is my first “pillar” of core because a good quality diaphragmatic breath:

  • Descends the diaphragm, smooshing down on your guts, which is necessary to generate intra-abdominal pressure so you can be strong AF when the demand arises (pillar 3)
  • Mobilizes the spine, pelvis and ribcage (pillar 2)
  • Lengthens all the abdominal muscles- A good indicator of their ability to then reflexively contract (Gary Ward’s rule: muscles lengthen before they contract)
  • Has implications for many, many physiological, neural, and esoteric things that are fascinating but beyond the scope of “core”

I really enjoy this animation of the biomechanics of the diaphragm, and the effect of diaphragmatic breathing on the whole body:

To make things very, very simple, in the session I demonstrated a 5 quadrant quick check for your quality of diaphragmtic breathing:

  1. Sternum and belly anterior (aka apical) expansion
  2. Lower pelvis anterior expansion
  3. Upper chest (aka pump handle ) expansion
  4. Lateral ribcage (aka bucket handle) expansion
  5. Posterior ribcage expansion

Are you able to access all 5? Are you all belly and no pump handle? Or are you like me and your left ribcage bucket handle never moves?

All 5 quadrants expanding simultaneously, effortlessly, and unconsiously is a good indicator of a quality diaphragmatic breath.

Core Training Pillar #2: Access to 3D spinal motion

First remember: Core training isn’t just about stabilizing and neutralizing the spine.

Second remember: Your spine moves when you walk (well it should, but maybe yours doesn’t… yet!.)

Third remember: Muscles lengthen before they contract.

Fourth remember: Joints act, muscles react.

So as a prerequisite to having abs that can contract and create stability, we need access to the specific 3D spinal motions that occur with each foot step you take:

Sagittal plane: Flexion and extension.

Frontal plane: Lateral flexions left and right.

Transverse plane: Rotations left and right.

In the session we covered a few exercises to experience the sagittal plane motions: Flexion and extension of the spine. And as a bonus we layered on the 5 quadrant breathing.

Greater access to the whole spine’s movement potential acctually gives you greater ability to stabilize it, too.

To help participants experience this, I had them test out a plank (holding for ~5 breaths), and gauge how “stable” they felt.

Then after exploring some spine motions, I had them re-test their plank. Here are some of their reactions:

“2nd time felt much stronger, more stable and able to access my breath more fully”

“Foot pressure balanced out – started really far on the left foot – more balanced. Also much more stable plank :)”

Pretty cool, eh?

Conclusions?

“Core” can mean a lot of things. What does core mean to you?

Many folks start core strengthening and stability training from the “outside in”, before considering the “inside” part: Breathing, spine motion, and center of mass mobility.

Ankle sprain rehab can be considered “indirect” core training, because it can give you greater access to move evenly between your two feet, aka “core mobility”, or “finding center”.

Neutral spine only lasts a fraction of a second when we walk- A fleeting moment in time.

Diaphragmatic breathing is not belly breathing- There are four other quadrants that need to expand with the belly with every inhalation. How’s yours doing?

Giving the abominal muscles the experience of how they actually lengthen and contract as we walk, by accessing three dimensional spine motion, should be the first poriority for core training, before training for stability.

Want to tune in live for part 2?

Save the date: Wed Jan 27th 2021 @ 10:30am EST (Torono)

In Core Training From the Inside Out )Part 2) we’ll review the first two pillars, and dive into 3 and 4:

  • Creating intra-abdominal pressure
  • Creating spine stiffness with limb movement

>>Sign up HERE<<

Can Your Feet Supinate? How to Check it and Why it Matters

The general vibe I get lately is that a lot more folks are open to the idea that pronation of the foot is actually useful. This is fantastic. In much thanks to the work of Gary Ward and all the amazing Anatomy in Motion peeps around the globe.

anatomy in motion wedges
Some of you might even own the ubiquitous AiM wedges to help your feet pronate more happily

I even got a delightful message last week from a lady asking how to help her daughter pronate her feet better. 

Wow! 

A few years ago nobody was asking how to pronate better. They (me included…) were condemning it and asking how to strengthen their collapsed arches. Preaching to push knees out over 5th toe. Walking on the outsides of their feet as a solution for over-pronation.

Times are changing, and I’m optimistic for humanity… Well, mostly.

But in all fairness, in Canada we have a “May 24 weekend”, that doesn’t always land on May 24, but we still call it that… I don’t get the logic.

With pronation coming out of purgatory, embraced by the masses, let’s not forget that it is just one of two complimentary extremes on a spectrum. Just because one is trending and useful, not to forget the other. 

Like when someone says “too many carbs are bad, go low carb!”, what do we do? EAT NO CARBS EVER because they are bad. 

Or when someone says “you should eat more fibre because it keeps you regular”, what do you do? EAT 5LBS OF BRUSSEL SPROUTS EVERY DAY, because more is better.  

Not that I’ve ever had problems with nuance, extremism, and carb-confusion. Not me. No way.

All that to say, let’s embrace pronation but…

DON’T FORGET THERE’S THAT OTHER THING THE FOOT DOES

Supination is still important. Always will be. 

Pronation and supination are a both/and combo, not an either/or. 

Doing something in an extreme, one-sided way should be practiced deliberately, like a medicine to restore balance. And an extreme medical intervention should not be permanent… 

The goal isn’t to only work on pronation forever, but to be constantly re-evaluating what balance means, and choose foot exercises with a clear intent.

So please, at the risk of pronating the crap out of our feet becoming the next “trendy” thing to do that gets grossly misinterpreted, people get hurt from it, and pronation becoming demonized yet again, remember that the main benefit of pronation is actually to help better supinate the foot.

This blog post is to offer a bit more info on supination of the foot:

  • What it is.
  • What is isn’t.
  • Can you do it well?
  • And what’s its relationship with pronation?

TWO FOOT SHAPES REVIEW

There are two main shapes the foot can make: Pronation, and supination.

What is Pronation? - Definition, Causes & Treatment | Study.com

If you’d like, you can go back and review my blog post about pronation.

Here’s a slide from day two (foot day) of my workshop, Liberated Body, to describe what to look for in an embodied experience of pronation and supination. Notice how they are the opposites:

anatomy in motion

Every movement the body can do takes place on top of either a pronating or supinating of foot, depending on the moment in time in the gait cycle. 

Some movements of the body happen only on a pronated foot, some happen on only a supinated foot, some happen on both, and some can happen on both but we don’t want to ever move that way if we value our joints… 

For example, a hip can flex while the foot is pronating or supinating. Both happen in gait and are healthy, useful options. 

Here is me flexing my left hip and *trying* to pronate my foot: Two motions which happen together in the loading phase of gait.
Here is me trying to flexi my left hip with a supinated foot (which happens in heel strike in gait)

However, hip extension should only happen on top of a supinating foot in gait. 

This is helpful to know so that when you’re doing exercises to work on hip flexion and extension you can accurately sync up your body with your feet.

If we’re not moving in consideration of the hip’s relationship with the foot, then we’re not actually teaching the body to do anything new. We’re just moving a hip in isolation from its role with the rest of the body. 

(There are many more examples of this, and if you’d like to learn more about foot/hip things, I recommend Gary Ward’s online course, Closed Chain Biomechanics of the Lower Limb).

MORE THAN JUST SHAPES…

Pronation and supination are best considered as verbs, not nouns.

They are words to describe very specific patterns of movement that all 26 moving bones and 33 joints of the foot do, in three planes of motion.

foot | Description, Drawings, Bones, & Facts | Britannica
Lots of bones down there folks!

Anything other than these specific patterns must be called something other than pronation and supination. If even one bone is going the wrong direction, it’s in foot purgatory. This degree of specificity is important.

(and if you have slightly OCD tendencies, you will love studying AiM.)

As verbs, the body should have dynamic access to both options end of the foot motion spectrum, never stuck in one or the other.

Now let’s dial in on supination. 

WHAT IS FOOT SUPINATION?

First, follow along with this demo, which is the supination self- check  from day 2 of Liberated Body:

So… Do your feet supinate well?

Here’s what we’re looking for as a felt experience of supination: 

  • All arches of the foot rising
  • Foot shortening and narrowing
  • Foot pressure distribution travelling to posterior lateral heel
  • Joints on dorsal (top) and lateral (outside) of foot opening
  • Muscles under the arch shortening
  • Muscles on dorsal, lateral foot and ankle lengthening
  • THREE POINTS OF FOOT TRIPOD ON THE GROUND (otherwise it’s not a real supination)

Could you feel all of that happening? 

WHAT IS SUPINATION NOT? 

Supination is NOT “arch strengthening”. 

Supination refers to motion between the bones of the feet. Actual moving joints. Not just contracting foot muscles to strengthen them.

You can strengthen a muscle without actually articulating the bones in a new way. You can only strengthen muscles within the constraints of your current options for joint movement.

Interestingly, arch strengthening drills like towel scrunching and practicing “short foot” may even block your ability to supinate well.  

Whilst towel srcunching, you may be inadvertently pressing your big toe into the ground to grip the towel. Alas… Big toe flexion is actually part of the collection of motions that happen in foot pronation. Oops! 

Pin on PreHab Exercises
If you’re squeeezing with your big toe, it ain’t supination anymore

I appreciate the valiant goal of the short foot exercise, however the foot is still being treated in isolation from the rest of the body, inconsiderate of the specifc pattern of triplanar motion that is supination. In particular, the rotational component of supination (transverse plane) is lost, which you can see (rather, not see…) in the video below.

I have no doubt you can strengthen your foot muscles and get better at short-footy, towel-scrunchies, but does that equate to moving those feet differently, unconsiously, whilst walking? And consider them in relation to the rest of the body?

Supination is NOT the same as rolling to the outside of your feet. 

That is just losing the tripod, which means you’re log-rolling the foot as a whole chunk, versus being able to articulate all joints with each other.

Remember, if you lose the tripod- 1st metatarsal contact, it is no longer supination. It’s inversion (aka how many ankle sprains happen).

ankle inversion
Loss of 1st met head contact= inversion: Aka oh shit there goes my ankle again!

It’s the difference between moving a collection of bones as a unit, through space, and moving the bones against each other, in one place, articulating on the ground. 

Supination is NOT the same as having high arches

You can have high arches but ankles that are actually internally rotated! 

Remember, as I hope you experienced in the supination check-in video above, we want the ankle to externally rotate with a supinating foot. But many folks with high arches actually have internally rotated ankles! 

Foot purgatory. Neither here nor there…

AN INTERDEPENDENT RELATIONSHIP

Pronation and supination together can be considered as a spectrum of movement we perpetually move through as we walk. 

They are Yin and yang. They are the opposite and complimentary movement of the other. They are interdependent, not independent.

Pronation relies on supination. Supination relies on pronation. Mess with one, and you impact the other.

In pronation, all the muscles that supinate the foot (primarily muscles attaching under the arch) get loaded eccentrically (stretched like an elastic band), providing the necessary stimulus to contract them, pick up the arch, and generate a healthy supination. 

This includes some lovely muscles like:

  • Flexor hallucis longus
  • Tibialis posterior
  • Peroneus longus
  • Tibialis anterior 
  • Soleus
  • Gastrocnemius
  • Et al.

Loading up these muscles generates the stimulus for supination.

Then the foot can start pronating again from it’s fully supinated position, instead of still being half-way (or all the way) pronated. This gives the foot more time before the arch completely lowers on the ground, preventing us from “over-pronating”, the foot crashing into the floor too quickly.

As a bad analogy, imagine if Johnny starts the 100m dash from the 50m line… He’s going to get to the finish line a lot faster than everyone else. But if your foot is like Johnny, starting to pronate from an already 50% pronated place, it will hit its full range a lot faster.

Johnny is like an over-pronating foot. 

Healthy pronation sets up an environment for a healthy supination by virtue of muscular contraction. 

Healthy supination sets up an environment for healthy pronation by virtue of allowing more time for pronation to take place within. 

CONCLUSIONS?

Don’t forget, in your excitement about pronation, that supination is important, too. 

A main goal of pronation is actually to help your foot supinate. 

A high arched foot is not the same thing as a supinated foot. 

If you lose 1st metatarsal head contact (tripod), it is no longer supination. 

Pronation and supination are interdependent, wholly reliant on one another. 

Eating 5lbs of fibre every day might make your guts hurt… Take it from me.

I’d love to hear if this blog post was useful for you. Did you try the foot supination check in? How did it go?

Again, helpful links if you’d like to learn more about your feet (and your body mechanics):

Closed Chain Biomechanics of the Lower Limb. The next best thing to do while you’re waiting to get into a real live Anatomy in Motion class again

You can get CPD credits 🙂

Liberated Body Workshop. If you want to learn to understand these mechanics better in your body, over 4 weeks of movement explorations.

anatomy in motion
I can’t give you CPD credits, but you get to hang out with me on Zoom 😉 Just as good, right??

Wake Up Your Butt

Every month I do a free movement session to help you understand a part of your body better.

Friday Nov 20th the topic of the monthly Movement Nerd Hangout was Wake Up Your Butt.

Before I go on and on in typical long-winded Monika fashion, check out the full 75ish minute session on Youtube:

SIDE NOTE: Interestingly, despite doing very little to promote it, this hangout, and being very, very tired on go-day, this session got the most positive response and highest attendance to date. Must be the magical allure of the glutes. After all, who can resist the promise of a stronger butt, more functional butt, and less irritating pain in the butt.

The rest of this blog post will be the technical/conceptual summary of the session.

Let’s begin with some basic functional anatomy…

Anatomy of your butt 101

(excluding sphincters, pelvic floor muscles, and your butt’s role in elimination…)

You have three glute muscles: Glute maximus, glute medius, and glute minimus.

Weak Gluteus Muscles and Lower Back Pain - Restore Health & Wellness
The gluteal muscles

Not to be confused with this silly depiction of the glutes show below.

Internet, please burn this photo. I feel a little ehtically awful for contributing to the mass distribution of abominable anatomical atrocities of the likes of this.

The glute muscles cross the hip joint, managing the motion of the pelvis and the femur.

The hip joint has lots of triplanar motion, which the glutes respond to by either shortening or lengthening. Here’s what the glute max does during each hip motion:

SAGITTAL PLANEGLUTE MAX STATUS
FlexionLong
ExtensionShort
FRONTAL PLANE
AdductionLong
AbductionShort
TRANSVERSE PLANE
Internal rotationLong
External rotationShort

However, glutes become tricky when we look at what they actually do in gait. During some phases the glutes can be long in two planes, and yet short in another! Muscles can be confusing…

For example, in the loading phase of gait- when the front foot pronates and our entire bodyweight is on it (aka suspension phase, in AiM) we have the following:

SAGITTAL PLANEGLUTE MAX STATUS
FlexionLong
FRONTAL PLANE
AdductionLong
TRANSVERSE PLANE
External rotationShort

And so at this point we shall switch gears from the traditional “what does that muscle do?” conversation…

Gary Ward’s First Two Rules of Motion

If you haven’t already read What The Foot, this is a good place to start to learn more about Gary’s 5 rules of motion.

What the Foot?: A Game-Changing Philosophy in Human Movement to Eliminate  Pain and Maximise Human Potential: Gary Ward: 9781907261084: Books -  Amazon.ca

The first two rules are very important for our glute discussion:

Rule 1: Joints act, muscles react

Rule 2: Muscles lengthen before they contract.

In gait, our muscles react to the movement of our bones and joints as we journey forward through space, from one foot to the next.

Walking is a predominantly momentum-based activity in which the role muscles contribute most strongly is to decelerate joint movement- Load up muscles like a slingshot, which then contract to move the bones in the opposite direction, then go on slack to let momentum do the rest. 

From this perspective, the solution to a sleepy butt is not just to squeeze it.

In gait, we do NOT want our muscles to only be concentrically contracting (shortening) to pick up our limbs and ambulate, which is a more energetically costly walking strategy. And we definitely don’t want to micro-manage every muscle contraction consciously.

Just think about the last time you had to walk in knee-high snow, and the feeling of having to contract your hip flexors more than necessary with each step. Tiring!

Unless you have a pair of snowshoes…

“You just can’t go anyplace without snowshoes”. I could listen this man talk all day! So soothing.

Think of muscles as managers of joint motion.

In gait, joints act, muscles react: Muscles manage the joint they cross by decelerating the motion of the bones that just moved into them, and sending them back the opposite direction, which generates our forwards locomotion. 

In efficient gait, glutes come alive, unconsiously, when the hip moves in such a way that lengthens them, providing the stimulus to contract back in the other direction.

This is important because each footstep you take contains all the building block joint motions that underlie every other movement pattern a human can do. If your hips can move with all their innate options, and glutes can load unconsciously while you walk, trust that your body has a much better chance of accessing them in all other activities.

Like deep-snow country snowshoeing

Now let’s apply this to the glutes, which manage the motion available at the hip.

What motions of the hip do the glutes manage? 

In any textbook or anatomy app, you’ll get the list of concentric joint actions a muscle does- What happens to the joint when that muscle shortens.

But you’ll probably never get the list of joint actions that muscle decelerates.

Key point: In gait, a muscle’s most important role is what it does eccentrically- A contraction while the muscle is lengthening.

Key question: What joint actions causes eccentric loading of the glutes?

Concentrically, the textbooks tell us that, at the hip joint, glute max will do:

  • Extension
  • Abduction
  • External rotation

Which means that to eccentrically load the glute max (in accordance with the rules joints act, muscles react, and muscles lengthen before they contract), we need the hip to do the opposite:

  • Flex
  • Adduct
  • Internally rotate

These three motions would lengthen glutes, which would then stimulate them to contract and create extension, abduction, external rotation, pushing us along our merry way.

So…

Flexing the hip gives no option but for glute max to generate hip extension

Adducting the hip gives no option but for the glute max to generate hip abduction

Internally rotating the hip blah blah blah hip external rotation.

So the question is not, “how many reps of side-lying clamshells should I do to activate my glutes?”, but rather “Can both of my hip joints access flexion, adduction, and internall rotation?”

Because if the hip joint can do those three motions, the glutes should have no option but to contract! 

Now of course there are many more muscles that cross the hip, which means we have a choice: Try to micromanage individual muscles OR, move the one hip joint in such a way it stimulates all said muscles to perform their role.

In Gary Ward’s words (from the Closed Chain Biomechanics of the Lower Limb course):

Looking at a single joint- the hip, will give us movement in every single muscles that is attached to it. So rather than thkning of working with 10 different muscles, we can still just focus on quality of movement in one joint.

It’s a great course FYI. And you can get continuing education credits at last!

Why do butts go to sleep?

The million dollar question: Why did your butts go “asleep” in the first place?

“Sleepy glutes” is a popular buzz term, and I am now guilty of propagating it (#marketing, yo). Calling any muscle “asleep” is a bit of an over-simplification.

Muscles don’t “sleep” exactly. They don’t have a REM cycle 😉 But they do adhere to the “use it or lose it” principle, and “joints act” is the “use it” that keeps us from losing our glute reaction.

Muscles “fall asleep” when we stop moving the joints they cross! Stop giving them anything to do, and they stop doing anything.

Most people’s technical solution to “waking up” a muscle is to repetitively contract it. Endless glute-squeezy activation drills. Thank you Jane Fonda.

Kick It Up a Notch” | Saved By Words

However, you can squeeze your butt all day and it might not result in any actual new joint motion.

Try it: You can squeeze your butt without moving your hips. But if you move your hip, you give your glutes no option but to respond.

Give the glutes no option but to contract

Imagine you’re 8 years old again, and it’s Christmas morning.

You’re wide awake and ready to open the presents under the tree, but Dad’s still half asleep because it’s at 5am on a Sunday and he just came back from working in the coal mines to buy you said presents (you ingrateful punk).

But you don’t care about Dad’s back-breaking manual labour, so you poke Dad over and over hoping he’ll wake up so you can open presents and eat candy for breakfast.

Well, poking Dad more won’t make him want to wake up, he’ll just get pissed off and want to stay in bed. Poking doesn’t provide the right incentive to change Dad’s behaviour. 

However you can give him no option but to wake up, by setting the Christmas tree on fire.

That’s the action that will stimulate sleepy ol’ Pops to move! 

Maybe this is a bad analogy, but what we want to do is stop poking Dad incessantly (squeezing glutes over and over), and instead create an environment in which he is given no choice but to wake up. Cruel… But does the job 😉

So how do we light that Christmas tree fire for your glutes? Create an environment that gives your glutes no option but to contract.  

Hip joint acts, glutes react. 

If the hip joint isn’t actually moving, the glutes won’t respond. This has nothing to do with how flexible or stiff you are. No actual motion of the hip= no glute reaction.  

Stop blaming your muscles

Far too often we blame muscles as the primary cause of our problems. But(t) unless there was direct trauma generating scar tissue (like sitting on a nail, a surgery, etc) it’s probably not orignally the muscle’s fault. 

Even a muscle strain might not originally be the muscle’s fault. After all, it was only doing what the joint’s access to it’s own motion permitted it to do.

Remember, in gait, the muscle’s role is to simply react to what the skeleton is capable of doing.

So don’t blame your glutes, they’re doing the best they can given their environment (aka the joint’s movement potential). Ask instead, “What might be preveniting my hip from moving?”

Well I don’t know what might be preventing YOUR hip joint from accessing it’s movement potential.

It could be a learned movement patterning based on a sport or skill.

Maybe an ankle sprain that makes you not want to put weight on that leg- and if you can’t put weight on a leg when you walk the hip joint isn’t going to move.

Or maybe you just sit a lot and literally just don’t move your hips.

Whatever the case may be, I hope this inspires you to to think and work with your hips and glutes in a new way.

Conclusions?

Muscles can be confusing, but if you can get your hip to move in all three planes, your glutes will have no option but to contract.

In gait, we are more interested in eccentric muscle action, because this is what most effectively stimulates a muscle to contract and move us forward.

Gait contains all the building block joint motions. Accessing glute function in the context of gait, by virtue of quality hip movement, opens the door of opportunity to use dem glutes in all other activities and exercises, unconsciously.

Ask not, how mnay reps of X-Magical-Glute-Exercise I should I do, and instead, seek to understand what could be preventing your hips from accessing tri-planar motion?

Now go any do all the glute things your heart desires 🙂 Do your squats, and glute bridges, barbell hip thrusts, clamshells, and side-lying leg raises, and trust you actually got glutes to squeeze.

Did you do the full movement session? Did you find it useful?

Did you find your glutes in all of the exercises? Was there one plane of motion that was harder than the other? Easier on one leg than the other? Shoot me an email or leave a comment below to share your experience 🙂

Let me know how it went 🙂

Are You Moving Honestly? This Fundamental Concept Will Change the Way You Move

This week I’d like to share a fundamental concept if you are trying to improve the way your body moves and feels.

Move. Honestly.

What does it mean to “move honestly”, and why is it important to understand and apply to your movement practice?

Grab a cup of coffee and hang out with me for 13 mins asI tell the story of a client and his scapulae to illustrate the concept of honest movement:

The above was originally a Facebook Live (you can see the unedited original here).

On the go? Listen to the audio-only version while you’re washing the dishes, saving the world’s bee population, waiting for your dog to take a poop, or whatever you do while listening to podcasts/radio/audiobooks.

What is moving honestly?

First, don’t feel bad… Not moving honestly doesn’t make you a bad person. It’s not a moral judgement. Simply a lack of awareness. And it’s OK, we’ve all got blind spots.

But, to quote Mark Manson’s PSA to millenials from his book, The Subtle Art of Not Giving a Fuck: “It’s not your fault, but it is your responsibility”.

Book Review and Questions on The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F
I really enjoyed this book when I read it as a 20-something year old

Now that you know moving honestly is a thing, it’s your responsibility to be aware of it. Sorry (not sorry), to burst your bubble.

Professor Google defines honest as: “Free of deceit and untruthfulness; sincere.” (Although I’d argue that honesty has a quality inherent to it that can’t be defined by the lack of something. Similarly to how “health” is more than simply the lack of illness… )

How can movement be insincere or deceitful? (again, I’m not implying you’re trying to deceive to people with movement… Unless you’re actually telling lies via sign language, or playing an evil character in physical theatre)

  1. When you can convince yourself that the current way of moving is all there is, the best way there is, and there’s nothing else to learn. Especially true when we’ve worked very hard to learn a skill, like ballet. Don’t ever tell a ballet dancer that they’re allowed to turn their legs in 😉 Just kidding…
  2. When your body has adopted a compensatory way of moving that you don’t even realize you’re doing– You think you’re moving the thing you’re trying to move, but you’re not…
  3. When you willingly compromise quality and accuracy of a movement to achieve an aesthetic, a fitness result, or an athletic goal, without considering the long-term implications. A client of mine who is a dance teacher really related to this. She reported that her students have no qualms sacrificing the alignment of their hips to make it look and feel like they are more flexible than they reallly are.

My definition of moving honestly: Moving in such a way that what your perception of what your body is doing is in alignment with what you’re actually doing, why you’re doing it, and you’re not denying that your current way of moving isn’t all that there is.

So it’s not moving “perfectly”. It’s about moving with awareness, as much self-objectivity as possible, and being open to what more could be available.

Perception vs. Reality

A good word to use is “actually”.

Profession Google defines actually as: “The truth or facts of a situation; really.”

Are you actually moving your spine or are you just shifting your weight around on your feet?

Are you actually rotating your shoulders externally or are you twisting out your forearms and wrists instead?

In the case of my client’s story, are you actually retracting your scapula or are you finding three other ways to do it that don’t remotely involve moving your scapula?

A little farther down in this post I’ll invite you to try the move-your-scaps-honestly challenge (as I described in the video… did you watch it to the end??). You might like to take a video of yourself, and check your perception vs. reality. What is your actual movement strategy?

How did we begin to move DIShonestly?

Why do we lie about anything? Because for some reason it served us.

We found a way to get what we wanted while conserving more energy: Taking short-cuts without understanding the repercussions.

Sometimes these are conscious choices. Sometimes a result of injury. Sometimes necessary for athletic performance.

As an example from my own life, the three most dishonest ways of moving I lived out:

  1. Lots of passive stretching when my structure couldn’t actually tolerate it: Being insincere to my golgi tendon organs. Sitting in the splits for 30 minutes straight is not very smart.
Golgi Tendon Organs and Muscle Spindles Explained | ACE
Sorry, muscle spindles, for the years of thrashing

2. Lots of heavy deadlifts when I couldn’t actually flex my hips without lumbar extension: Failing to see my true biomechanical needs and abilities. I got pretty strong, but at a cost. Working with a coach earlier would have helped.

3. Lots of high intensity exercise when what I actually needed was to rest and recover from injuries, but I was scared by the dance-world’s focus on being thin: Not being true to me, and using exercise to control my appearance, based on how I thought the dance-world wanted me to look.

Do any of these resonate with you?

Moving dishonestly can range from a simple lack of awareness easily remediated with a technical cue, to a more severe, systemic issue in which our entire movement practice is out of congruence with our values, needs, and goals.

Biomechanical honesty

Biomechanical honesty refers to being able to move every bone and joint as per its original intructions, with awareness.

Movement based on the actual joint architecture. According to our anatomical set-up. The shape of the bones themselves dictate how they are able to move.

Dishonesty happens every time we lose an option to move as per our original instructions, and replace it with something else less precise, less pure, less “true”, without us knowing.

Or every time we put our faith in someone elses’ movement system that is not congruent with the actual movement possible based on the articulating surfaces of our bones, and the lines of pull of our muscles, because their biomechanical understanding is hazy.

For example, THIS representation of the gluteal muscles:

Face palm 🙁

So be careful who you learn from (even me…).

Speaking of glutes, I once believed that squeezing my glutes as I walked was a good way to “activate” them, because I heard someone say that, and started doing it. Not really how the body works, but my naive self didn’t know better at the time…

So what causes us to lose an option for honest movement?

  • Injuries not completely healed that we learn to adapt around
  • Trained movement skills (sports, yoga, etc)
  • Being told to stand and walk a particular way (don’t walk pigeon-toed, stand up straight)
  • Long periods of being mostly sedentary
  • Repetitive habits (like always sitting with one leg crossed)
  • Early childhood sensory-motor deprivation
  • Weird birth experiences

All of the above experiences can distort our perception of how we’re moving because they all will result in the distortion of our movement mechanics from its original instructions.

Not “bad”. Just not how we came in our original packaging.

Harrison Ford Signed "Star Wars: Return of the Jedi" Han Solo Action Figure  in Original Packaging (PSA LOA) | Pristine Auction
You gotta step out of the original packaging to live your life… But at least try to remember what it was like!

Judgement and attachment in motion

Sometimes we get overly attached to particular ways of moving and deliberately avoid movements we were taught are “bad”.

As a ballet dancer, I believed for years that hip internal rotation was bad, and refused to consider otherwise. External rotation was a badge of honour, even if it was hurting me.

You might also have been told that slouching is bad, letting your pelvis hike in the frontal plane (sassy hips) is bad, or pronating your feet is the devil.

In fact, I had a client once tell me that as a yong woman, she was shamed for appearing “too sexual” by authorities in her Christian community for letting her pelvis hike while she waked. So she deliberately stopped doing it. Now, years later, our work together involves helping her re-experience this movement with the understanding that its actually crucial for shock absorption mechanics in gait. Oops…

Moving honestly, for her, means embracing, de-vilifying, and remembering her original instructions for pelvis movement.

The confabulating body

Confabulation is when we’re lying but we think we’re telling the truth. We don’t even know we’re being dishonest because we lack sufficient information to know any better!

Our bodies are excellent confabulators. And thank goodness they are!

Like my client who stopped hiking her pelvis, her clever body figured out multiple strategies to make up for it because our bodies are always 100% functional to keep us moving.

Threfore, the better you are at confabulating, it is a sign of just how functional your body is.

But there comes a tipping point at which the number of confabulations becomes too high and your body can’t keep up with the demand.

Like if you’ve ever tried to lie to 10 different people at once, each with a different story, and you lose track of your stories and eventually get caught and things blow up in your face…

So what happens when your body exceeds its capacity to confabulate? What if you run out of available body parts to subsitute with?

This is the law of compensation and adaptation: As long as compensation is possible, progression of the problem is imperceptable. It is when all the adaptive processes have been exhausted that the symptom suddenly appears. (from osteopath Jean-Pierre Barral’s Visceral Manipulation textbook)

The solution is to strip things back to their original instructions, so that body parts are both independednt and interdependent, not co-dependent, caught in eachothers’ web of lies.

This is challenging when multiple body parts are engaged in what Anatomy in Motion instructor Chris Sritharan calls a “negotiation”. How does one resolve a negotiation? Lots of honest, open, conversations…

Which isn’t fun and sexy… But rewarding, if you do the work.

The move-your-scaps-honestly challenge

Would you like to give this “honest movement” thing a try, and give your body a chance to have an honest conversation between its various parts?

In the video at the beginning of this post, I invited you to try the exercise I gave my client: To find pure, honest scapular retraction without using any confabulatory strategies.

Are you up for the move-your-scaps-honestly challenge?

Here’s a version of the exercise I gave my client to explore scapular retraction and protraction. Try it out and see if you can do it honestly 😉

As you go through the exercise, try to be aware of whether or not you are using any of the following strategies:

  • Elevation of your scapulae
  • Depression of your scapulae excessively
  • Rotating or bending your whole body to one side
  • Extending your lumbar spine excessively
  • Pulling your arms behind you
  • Probably other stuff!

Using a mirror or filming yourself might help to catch your blind spots.

Remember, it’s not about BIG movement. It’s about moving differently, accurately, purely.

This might mean moving througha smaller range of motion, but more purely and precisely, with the actual body part you intend to move.

Or maybe finding an entirely new pathway for movement that you didn’t know existed.

4 guidelines for moving honestly

As you do the honest scapular motion challenge, these four guiding principles for honest movement might help. They are very similar to Anat Baniel’s 9 guidelines from her book Move Into Life.

Move Into Life: NeuroMovement for Lifelong Vitality: Baniel, Anat, Waldman,  Mark Robert: 9781519438881: Books - Amazon.ca
I really enjoyed reading thsi book, until I had to stop and remediate my book addiction.

4 Guidelines for Honest Movement Exploration

  1. Move slowly. When you move quickly, all you can do is move the way you already know how. Slow. Down. Think milimeters per second, not miles per hour.
  2. Move with moment to moment awareness. Pay attention to the bones and joints your’re trying to move. Can you visualize and feel them moving? What muscular sensations do you notice? How are you distributing your weight in your feet? Are you doing werid things with your neck? Are you clenching your jaw? What new sensation of your body in motion can you tune into today? What new detail about your body’s preferred movement strategies can you disccover?
  3. Use external boundaries for feedback. Like I did for my client with my hands, it can be helpful to set up your environment with bumpers and boundaries for external feedback so that you can move honestly without hurting your brain. Chairs, walls, bands, etc. There are a ton of creative ways to create an environment condusive to honest movement, when you know it likes to confabulate 😉 This is also where a movement coach or guide can be of great assistance.
  4. Move small and subtle. Much like moving quickly, when you move big, all you can hope to do is what you already CAN do, just bigger. Lasting freedom is unlocked milimeter by milimeter.

These four guidelines will help you reduce your tendency to use cheaty strategies, and confabulate, and help you to move more honestly.

Conclusions?

The more honestly you can move, the less strain there will be on your system, with each body part being able to do what it was originally designed to do, in isolation, and integrated with the whole bdoy.

Just like the chronic liar who gets caught in the stress of having to keep up with all the stories and webs of lies… Life is easier when we’re being honest. With ourselves, our bodies, and how we move.

Start by trying the move-your-scaps-honestly cahllenge a try, and let me know what you find.

Get help from a coach or movement professional when necessary.

And remember, it’s not a moral judgement, just a call for higher awareness, and to investigate if there could be a more useful way of moving.

Want more help moving honestly?

I’ve pretty much dedicated my life to practicing honest movement (a brutal, life-long process for me it appears…) So I created a workshop with that in mind 🙂

My workshop Liberated Body guides you through an exploration of your body’s movement mechanics based on what it ought to be able to do through the gait cycle (if you still had your original packaging).

The next 4 week workshop is coming up on November 23. You can learn more about it and register HERE.

anatomy in motion

Liberated Body is a little different than other movement workshops. The goal isn’t even to move “better”, but let your body decide for itself what “better” means, based on honest investigation into your current options for movement. What more is possible? Only one way to find out…

Two of my students, Garrett and Maggie, sent me deligftul videos describing the process they went through doing Liberated Body. And while they didn’t use the words “honest movement”, I think that’s exactly what they’re describing.

Check out their sucess stories, they really made me smile and blush:

That’s all for now folks. May you move inquisitively, honestly, and with ease 😉

Calcaneal Motion 101: A Movement Detective’s Complete Guide to Setting the Heel Bone Free

Last Friday my weekly Movement Deep Dive session was all about calcaneal motion: Let Your Heel Bone Slide!

Before you read the rest of this blost, take a moment to get in the mood with da Maestro himself:

I’m not sure WHICH of the 33 vertebrae Maestro is referring to by “backbone”… But for today I will opportunistically pretend he’s talking about the pelvis (including the 9 total vertebrae of the sacrum and coccyx), because that makes for a smoother segway into today’s topic…

A movement detective’s comprehensive guide to calcaneal motion!

In today’s post and series of six tutorial videos, we’ll be covering:

  1. What is the heel bone (calcaneus)?
  2. What motions does this bone do in three dimensions when we walk? And can your calcaneus access those triplanar motions?
  3. How should calcaneal motion couple with pelvis and skull motion in the gait cycle for more ease and efficiency?
  4. Could a movement restriction at your calcaneus be impacting on movement of your pelvis of skull (reducing or liberating)?

If you don’t want to read, simply follow along with the videos and explore your own calcaneal motion- The embodied learning approach is better anyway 😉

But first… The basics.

What is the calcaneus?

The calcaneus is the big sturdy bone at the back of your foot.

Heel Fractures - Peninsula Podiatry

It articulates with the talus above, the cuboid on the lateral side, and the navicular on the medial side.

Its the bone that first meets the ground in the heel strike phase of gait, so it has a nice cushy layer of fat to help it absorb the shock from each foot step.

CalexFit, Foot Pain Relief Center - Conditions - Fat Pad Atrophy
The heel bone: The one place you want to be fat.

The achilles tendon, plantar fascia, along with 9 muscles of the foot and lower leg attach to the calcaneus, including soleus and gastrocnemius (the two big juicy calf muscles).

So whenever there is an issue with any of those muscles, like achilles tendinitis, plantar fasciitis, or any other “itis” of the foot, we should get on our detective hats and look at how well the calcaneus can move.

Got a big toe issue, like a bunion? Hammer toes? Limited big toe extension? Other weird toe stuff I’ve never heard of?? The infamous flexor hallucis longus (flexor of the big toe) does not actually attach to the calcaneus, but has its own special groove that runs along the medial side of the calcaneus, behind the sustentaculum tali.

Flexor Hallucis Longus Tendonitis - PhysioAdvisor

Your calcaneus should be able to move in three dimensions while you walk so that all it’s attaching musculature and tissues can lengthen and contract with every step you take.

Motion of the calcaneus, and its neighbour the ankle, also play an important role in venous return– Pumping the blood back up to the heart, because gravity makes that a little harder.

rfumsphysiology / Cardiovascular Response to Stressor

One reason people may get varicose veins is because of an increase of blood pressure in the venous system because the blood isn’t pumping effectively back up to the heart. Making sure the heel and ankle complex can move optimally to prevent venous blood backflow can reduce the chance of varicosity and distortion of the veins.

So… Calcaneal motion is kind of important!

Unfortunately many of us have restrictions in one or more planes of calcaneal motion (me included!), which can lead to a multitude of whole body issues, not only locally at your foot.

What if your heel bone can’t slide?

As mentioned above, one could experience any number of effects, ranging from local stuff such as a knee issue or plantar fasciitis, to distal issues like neck restriction and discomfort (stay tuned for how to assess that in part 6 of this calcaneal motion 101 video series).

The following two videos are clips, from Friday’s Let Your Heel Bone Slide session, to acquaint you with your calcaneus.

And now let’s take a look at the tri-planar movements your calcaneus ought to be able to do, and how to name them. We’ll be using the same langauge we’d use to name the movement of the pelvis (if you took my Liberated Body workshop, or are an Anatomy in Motion student, this will be familiar):

Being able to name and feel the motions a part of your body should be able to do is important in healing our bodies, and re-patterning movement. However, a barrier can be that every school of thought seems to use their own preferred anatomical langauge, and when everyone’s using different words to describe the same movements it can be super confusing!

The nomenclature I chose may not be the most “text-book-technical” anatomical verbiage, or sound fancy, but it is accurate and specific to describing the bone’s motion. So for those of you who are interested, here’s a little “univeral translation” chart:

TRIPLANAR CALCANEAL MOTION:

Sagittal Plane Frontal PlaneTransverse Plane
Pelvis languageAnterior and posterior tiltHiking and droppingRotation right and left
Anatomical languagePlantar and dorsiflexionEversion and inversionInternal and external rotation
Foot pressure distribution12 o’clock: Front (anterior)3 and 9 o’clock (medial and lateral)3 and 9 o’clock (medial and lateral)

I really don’t care what words you use. You can make up your own terms, as long as you and your body know what’s happening.

Also note that in the video I am exagerating the size of calcaneal motions. In reality, they are much smaller. Calcaneus motion also happens concurrently with motion of the rest of the foot (and the rest of the body…), not in isolation, to give us pronation and supination.

Let’s move along and look at how the backbone and heel bone slide together.

What motion relationship do the calcaneus and pelvis have in gait?

This is where can start to have a little fun (if you’re a movement nerd like me).

The pelvis and calcaneus have a specific movement relationship in gait that should happen unconsciously for efficiency with each step.

Before I say more, check out this next clip:

In case you didn’t watch the video: When you walk, your calcaneus, pelvis, and skull move in the same directions, in all three planes of motion, at all times. Cool right?

So…

When your pelvis rotates right (which happens whenever you step forwards with your left leg), both heel bones, and your skull should also be rotating to the right right.

When your pelvis anteriorally tilts, so too should your calcaneus and skull.

Now, I know you’re dying to check and see if these movement relationships are present for your body, right? 😉

The next three videos are guided check-ins will help you do that:

  • #1 How well can your calcaneus move?
  • #2 How well does your calcaneus move in harmony with your pelvis?
  • #3 How could a lack of calcaneal motion impact (restrict or liberate) motion at your pelvis and skull?

Calcaneus movement check-in

This first little check-in is to feel if your calcaneus moves appropriately while you are weight-bearing onto your leg.

Could you feel the movement from back, outside corner to front-inside corner of your heel when you bent your knee? Or did you skip right forwards into your forefoot and toes?

Now let’s bring your pelvis into the equation…

Pelvis and calcaneus movement check-in

In this next video, we’ll be checking in to see if your pelvis and calcaneal movements are synced up for ease and flow as you walk.

It’s not enough just to be able to move your calcaneus on its own. Does it move in the right relationship with your pelvis? Follow along and see what you find:

Are your pelvis anterior and posterior tilts synced up with your calcaneus anterior and posterior tilts? How about the hikes, drops, and rotations? What’s missing from your movement map?

Lastly, let’s tune in to see if your calcaneal motion has an impact up the chain, at your pelvis, neck, and skull.

How does calcaneal motion impact on neck motion?

What if a movement restriction at your calcaneus, due to an old ankle sprain for example, could be related to a movement restriction at your neck?

This final video is by far the most fun to play along with! Give yourself 10 minutes to geek out on how movement of your heel could be influencing stuff all the way up to your neck:

My personal findings:

To use me as an example, in the chance it helps you interpret your own data…

If I prop my calcaneus into more anterior tilt it frees my neck in both flexion and extension in the sagittal plane.

When I nudge my left calcaneus into a left hike- outside edge higher, more pressure on the inside edge (ie eversion) my neck motion into lateral flexion to the right (left skull hike) feels much happier.

So when I give my calcaneus(es) (calcanei?) back what’s missing, it has a positive effect on structures above.

So could it be that a “neck problem” might have a component to it that involves the foot?

Could it be that a hip problem is related to a heel that can’t move?

These things are good to know so we can approach any issue at one part of the body as a whole body issue.

This has become the over-arching intention of my Movement Deep Dive sessions: Let’s understand, explore, and restore the body’s potential for movement, one part at a time. Zooming in, zooming out, and integrating it all as a whole.

Conclusions?

Your calcaneus moves in three dimensions as you walk. Unless it doesn’t 😉

This three dimensional motion should occur in a specific interaction with pelvis and skull motion: Your heel, pelvis, and skull travel in the same direction, in all three planes, with every step you take.

A neck restriction could be related to a calcaneal motion restriction, and wouldn’t you want to know abut that? I sure would, so I can stop stretching my neck and get to the real root of the issue.

If you would like to learn even more about foot mechanics and how to use your “calcaneus influecing tools” more effectively, I recommend you check out Gary Ward’s online course Wake Your Feet Up. You’ll even get a set of official AiM wedges mailed to you, and more instructions for how to use them. But in the meantime, I’ve found that socks and towels work just fine 😉

Using AiM wedges to promote new foot motion in pronation. A rather exterme example of wedge use for a rather extreme set of feet… Don’t start here.

This leads us into to one final important question regarding footwear..

Are you wearing shoes that could be messing with your pelvis and neck?

It’s quite possible…

If a foot motion restriction could lead to a neck restriction, then could a shoe that restricts foot motion also restrict motion elsewhere? For sure!

In fact, I have a system you can use to check that out for yourself.

My inaugural monthly Movement Nerd Hangout in September was dedicated to testing out whether your shoes or orthotics are working for you, or messing with your body.

Check out the entire 90 minute session, Are Your Shoes Working For You? for free, and get the PDF handout I created to test and document allll of your shoes.

That’s it for today folks 🙂 I hope you had fun exploring your bones and practicing your DIY movement detective skills with me today.

Feel free to share this blog post and video series with people in your life with stiff feet, or if you think it offers a useful perspective. And let me know what you discovered about YOUR calcaneal motion when you have a spare moment 🙂

[et_bloom_inline optin_id=”optin_10″]

Current Exercise Obsession: 8 Reasons Why I Love the Forearm Press

I don’t usually write blog posts to romance one particular exercise, but today I need to confess my love for the forearm press.

The trouble with putting any exercise on a pedestal is that one person’s best exercise is another person’s worst. One person’s medicine is another’s poison. So take this all with a grain of salt 😉

Before I say more about why I love the forearm press, and why it’s a staple in my current movement practice, check out this quick tutorial by moi:

I edited this clip from one of my weekly Movement And Strength Training Foundations online classes, also known as “Struggle-Along With Monika Doing Basic Bodyweight Exercises”.

Because the basics never get old…

To the outside observer, this exercise looks like the most boring thing in the world. Internally, however, its very exciting.

Don’t be deceived by the simplicity or basic-ness of the forearm press!

As many of my clients will attest, this exercise is not just chilling-out on your forearms, its freakin’ intentional work. And the benefits are in the details.

So the rest of this blog post is allll about the details.

You can build shoulder health and strength simultaneously

In my own journey to shoulder health and strength, I did pretty much everything wrong.

I just wanted to be able to do pushups and chin ups and over-head pressing and one-armed handstands, but I didn’t even know what a shoulder was, nor was I doing anything useful to prepare my shoulders for the movement capacity and positional integrity those exercises require.

You can learn from my mistakes.

The forearm press is where I wish I started my arm-strength jounrye.

It is an awesome way to set that foundation and build a solid AF shoulder girdle so you can do all the upper body things.

So here’s the top 8 reasons why I’m loving the forearm press right now as a shoulder health and strength development exercise.

8 reasons why I love the forearm press

1. Get a “neck stretch” while you get stronger

This exercise builds mad shoulder strength while giving you a great upper back, upper trapezius, and neck stretch at the same time. In fact, feeling the neck and upper trap stretch is an indicator that you’re in a good position.

If you set up the forearm press corretctly, you should be able to feel a bit of stretch on the back of your neck and your upper traps. Isn’t that a great bonus?

In fact, in the forearm press, a lot of the work you will feel is coming from muscles working in a lengthened position- An eccentric muscle action.

Here are some of the muscles that are getting this lovely stretchy, worky opportunity in the forearm press, besides your neck and upper traps:

  • Triceps (via elbow flexion, shoulder flexion)
  • Rhomboids (via scapular protraction, upward rotation)
  • Posterior deltoids (via scapular protraction, arm horizontal adduction)
  • Lats (via shoulder external rotation, shoulder flexion)
  • All the traps- upper, middle, and lower (via scapular protraction and depression)
  • Cervical spine extensors (neck flexion, scap depression)

If you’d like to really nerd out, some muscles will be working in both a long and short position at the same time, in different planes of motion. Fun eh?

Let’s take the lats, for example: You should feel a bit of lat stretch by virtue of the scapular protraction and the fact that your arms are in front of your body (shoulder flexion). However, at the same time, your lats need to act concentrically to hold your shoulders down from your ears (scapular depression).

Two Minutes of Anatomy: Latissimus Dorsi - YouTube

What I hope you can take away from that is that it is often more productive to cue yourself with joint movements (push the floor away, scaps towards your butt pockets) than muscle actions (engage your lats!).

If I say to you, “Use your lats!”, what joint action it that asking for? This muscle crosses multiple joints… Which joint are we even talking about?? Should you “use your lats” eccentrically or concentrically? (And now you know the answer is BOTH).

2. Scapular protraction strength: Push before you pull?

Note that the forearm press is a pushing exercise.

Pushing implies you DO NOT want to squeeze your shoulder blades together. The main joint action in the forearm press is scapular protraction, which you get by pushing the floor away to spread your scaps wider apart.

Contrary to what some folks think, shoulder blades back and down is not the epitome of shoulder health, stability, or “good posture”. In fact, in any arms supported work, we want to spread those scaps and push the floor down (protraction).

What about the 3:1 pull to push ratio?

I don’t know if this is a thing anymore, but when I first began working as a trainer I was taught that in an optimal training program, one should have a 3:1 ratio of upper body pulling to pushing exercises.

So for exmaple, for every push-up, there should be three rowing exercises.

I don’t know if I agree with this.

I feel that a lot of folks can get more out of initially working on pushing, rather than starting with pullling. But that doesn’t mean be silly like me and start with 26 different push-up exercises…

Here’s my main case for push first, and how the forearm press serves as an awesome pushing experience:

Muscles lengthen before they contractGary Ward‘s 2nd rule of movement.

This refers to how, in gait, muscles are stimulated to generate a contraction from their fully lengthened position. Like pulling back an elastic band in order to project it forward. Muscles load to explode.

While this is describing muscles in the context of gait, I think it also applies to strength training.

When we push, and protract the scapuale, the muslces of retraction (like the rhomboids, middle trapezius, and pals) lengthen, loading them eccentrically (like pulling back the slingshot).

Top 3 Exercises for Stronger Scapular Retraction and Depression - Shoulder  Blades Back

So if we are strategically thinking ahead, we can prepare the muscles that retract the scaps (pictured above) by first training them to load eccentrically, using pushing movements that protract the scaps.

Give the rhomboids and traps no option but to contract, by first lengthening them.

It’s not about “stretching” them. The stretch is simply an indicator of scapulae that are actually protracting, giving the the muscles of retraction the stimulation to contract from a more lengthened position, ultimately improving their strength and function.

But what about developing rounded-forwards shoulders?

Many of us have been given and idea that to stand with “good posture” is to pull our shoulders back. And yet many folks have shoulder problems because of this.

I can recall two recent clients in particular with severely retracted scapulae who could barely budge them apart from each other, and had “shoulder and neck stiffness”.

Upon asking, one of them told me she was raised by nuns who demanded “shoulders back” all day long. The other is a lady in her 70s who was perpetually told by her mom not to slouch when she was a kid.

Got shoulder problems? Blame the church and your mom 😉 Just kidding…

Pushing exercises that demand scapular protraction, can help us find a more balanced, centered way, naturally, by showing our shoudler girdle to both ends of the the shoulder girdle protraction to retraction spectrum.

I like the forearm presss for this because it helps liberate both our mind and body from learned postural propaganda.

Here’s another little video clip on the topic of “good posture” (from one of my Movement Deep Dive sessions):

One of my online students actually remarked how it felt like her shoulders were in a more naturally “held back” position, even though the forearm press deliberated asks you NOT to squeeze your shoudlers together: Protraction, not REtraction.

Another friend/client of mine gave this feedback afte doing this exercise with me in one of my online classes:

So that is why I like to use pushing exercises before pulling (rows, chin-ups, etc). And the forearm press accomplishes this nicely.

3. Awesome preparation for more advanced upper body weight bearing exericses

Mastery of this position will build a foundation for anything else that requires weight-bearing into yours arms with a solid shoulder girdle.

For example:

  • Static beast and crawling progressions (for the Animal Flowists)
  • Plank and push-up variations
  • Dolphin, forearm stands, and headstand variation, and other arm balancing postures common in yoga, like crow and crane
  • Handstands (my current training obsession)
  • Other fun floor-based flowy movement stuff, a la Ido Portal, or Animal Flow.

4. Safe exercise for most folks with wrist complaints

Many of my in-person clients are women. Most of them are in their 50s/60s and are learning to support themselves on their arms for the first time ever. Back in the 1950s-70sish days, strength training wasn’t a thing many women were encouraged to do.

Well times are a changin’. And developing arm strength to hold onesself up off the floor is an uber empowering thing for all genders.

However, due to never actually training hand supported positions, many peoples’ wrists might not be comfortable in extension with their bodyweight loaded on top of them.

Being on the forearms makes weight-bearing through the arms possible even for people with cranky wrists, so they can start training their shoulder girdle position and strength without putting compressive strain on their wrists.

5. You get great feedback from the floor and no fancy equipment or expensive coach required

I love my daily floor time (the floor is actually one of my top 3 favourite tools for moving with more ease and less pain, I wrote about in my 3 Essential Tools PDF resource, have you read it yet?).

Putting our forearms or hands on the floor creates a closed-chain environment.

Closed-chain upper body exercises gives us amazing feedback about our body position, no coach or special equipment required.

In the forearm press, here’s a few ways the floor can give you great feedback to help execute the exercise with better quality and precision without someone like me hovering over you, yelling commands:

Deliberately push against the floor: The real work and intensity comes from pushing your forearms down into the floor really hard, like you’re pushing right to China. Or if you live in China, push your way to America (but not so hard you strain and hyperventilate…).

Notice your body position in relation to the floor : As you hold, get your position cues from the floor:

  • Do you see the floor moving closer to your face? This might mean your head is changing from it’s start position, drooping lower. Don’t let the floor get closer to your face.
  • Can you push your chest up higher from the floor- maintain the “press” part (scapular protraction)?
  • As you do the rocking forwards variation (did you watch the tutorial?), use the floor as something to aim your forehead for to gauge the distance you’re moving. Every time you practice, try to rock farther towards the floor.
  • Feel your hand and arm contact against the floor: Can you get all 5 hand knuckles on the floor? How about your wrists? Do your hands slowly start to move more and more inward of your elbows as you hold? Try to hold firm contact of all knuckles, wrists, and elbows- It changes the way it feels and helps you develop a more powerful push.

Being aware of where all your body parts are on and in relation to the floor helps you helps you be your own best coach. Since many of us are working out at home these days with no outside eye, the floor is a great tool, built into the forearm press, at no extra cost 😉

6. Tons of fun progressions to challenge your whole body

There are endless forearm press variations to play with when you’ve mastered the basics and are ready to progress the challenge level!

Here’s one progression that’s been a staple for me for the past couple of months: The knees hovering elbow bend (don’t have a fancy name for it…). Welcome to tricep city.

I originally stole this from Lizette Pompa, realized how hard it was, and reverse engineered it back to the forearm press, because that was honestly where I should have started. Basics…

Here’s Lizette making it look oh-so effortless. And notice how she can do it without rocking her butt back to her heels, like I have to do, making it a more pure upper body exercise:

7. Ability to self-modulate the intensity purely with your intention

Working out at home without equipment means we have to find other clever ways to modulate exercise inensity than adding external resistance (weights).

As I often say to my clients/students, you can make this exercise as hard or as easy as you want simply through your intention to do so.

Find your own specific intensity threshold at which you can perform the exercise with good quality, maintain your structural integrity, and still be able to breathe (use your quality of breathing to gauge your intensity threshold, ie if you start to hyperventilate, you’re done).

  • Push down the floor more (make it more intense) or less (less intense).
  • Hold for longer (more breath cycles) or shorter.
  • Focus on keeping your body more forward on your arms (harder), or back slightly off your arms (easier).

Little tweaks to where you’re focusing and fine-tuning your body positioning help this become harder or easier without even having to move to a more “advanced” variation.

8. Becomes a lovely way to tune into breathing mechanics

In this position we can get a few really nice things, breathing mechanics-wise:

  • With scaps protracted, all the muscles of the upper back are lengthened, and the area called the posterior mediastinum can open up. The posterior mediastinum (see photo below) can get a little squashed, and some vital tubes and things pass through this very small region. Keeping it open and breathing into it is important for both general health and movement reasons. Push the floor, expand your upper back, breathe into it, and enjoy the extra space between your lungs and spine.
Posterior Mediastinum
  • With the head a bit lower than the hips- a slight inversion, this position also helps enhance the “pump handle” breathing action of the upper chest- Forwards and upwards expansion. See what I mean by pump-handle in this cool animation of breathing mechanics
  • The forearm press position makes it easier to hold the ribcage slightly “exhaled” and down, which helps to more easily access the abdominal muscles and create greater intra-abdominal pressure. This helps one to access a better diaphragmatic breating pattern, without flaring open the ribcage excessively with each breath, with better abdominal co-contraction, which means hello abz.

Conclusions?

I love this exercise because it makes my shoulders and neck feel awesome. Like I got a great workout and an upper trap stretch at the same time.

But you are not me…

Most people don’t have any problems with it, but if you do, don’t force through it! Get some help if you have pain with this or any movement.

The forearm press is wonderful for both shoulder health and strength, and is also a gateway to more advanced arm balancing exercises, like headstands, and handstands, if that’s a thing you have on your movement-goals-list.

So if you want to build a solid handstand from the ground up, I would start here, with the forearm press. Basics, basics, basics!

Want to be able to do push-ups really well? I would start here.

Even just to be able to do set your shoulder girdle up for a perfect plank position, I would start here.

Don’t be like silly, young Monika. Start your shoulder strength journey from the ground up, and enjoy more linear progress because you won’t have to go back and work on the basics later, after experiencing discomfort, like me.

Give it a try, and let me know how it goes for you! I’d love to hear how the forearm press feels for you. Love it or hate it? Probably a little of both 😉

In my Movement and Strength Training Foundations online classes we worked on the forearm press for four weeks straight. If you’d like to learn more about these classes or try one out, shoot me an email 🙂

Sacroiliac Joint 101: What is the SIJ and How to Self-Assess (in less than 8 mins)

Do you have a deep achey painy thing between your butt and your back, and you’re not sure if it’s lower back pain or butt pain?

That’s probably your sacroiliac joint. And we can totally figure it out 🙂

In this blog post I’m going to share some video clips from my Troubleshooting the SI Joint (part 1) Movement Deep Deep session from Sept 18 2021 help you work with that poor, misunderstood SI joint of yours.

Yes I am an excellent photo editor. Check out my IG account for more excellent work like this @monvolkmar

How to be a DIY SIJ Detective

Quick back-story: I became a self-appointed DIY movement detective by sheer necessity.

At age 22 I was broke and broken from my career in dance (marry rich, one prof told us).

I had no money to get physical therapy (literally like $500 in my account, the remnants of my student loan not even my own money), no future as a dancer, and a part time customer service job at the local Goodlife Fitness (when they changed the title “Customer Service Rep” to “Motivator” and I knew I had to get out of there…).

What I did have was time and hunger to understand my body.

The insight struck me as I limped to the physio clinic one day to get yet another ineffective treatment: I have to become my own best therapist. No one can do this for me, or care more about me more than me.

That limp was my victory march, and the beginning of my journey as a DIY movement detective.

As the beloved Buddhist teacher Pema Chodran wrote in her book, When Things Fall Apart, “We’re here to study ourselves. Studying ourselves provides all the books we need.”

When Things Fall Apart : Pema Chodron : 9781570621604
A fantastic book for anytime, but particularly for right now

I’ve come to see my body is my best textbook. All the info I need is within it.

Saying this because if you’re in a similar place- you’ve realized that only YOU can figure you out, then what I have to share today will help your investigations.

So before you hop on Youtube and do a search for “How to make my SIJ stop hating me”, let’s see if we can help orient you to your SI joint by opening the textbook of You.

Time to get off the lacrosse ball you may be sitting on, cursing your pririformis as the root of all evil, and get to learning 🙂

SIJ Made 10-Year-Old Simple

I’m not claiming I know everything about the SIJ. Not even close…

My hope is that the two video clips in this post will help orient you to 1) What your SIJ is and, 2) Why it might feel like it does from a movement perspective.

From there, you can make better informed decisions about WHAT to do about it.

This first clip covers:

  • What the heck is the SI joint anyway?
  • How much movement does it actually have?
  • What primary purpose does SIJ motion serve in gait?
  • What two simple terms can we use to name SIJ movement that even a 10 year old can understand?

Want to see the 60 second version? Check it out here on my Instagram account.

Side note: After editing this video I’ve now heard the word “SI joint” so many times it doesn’t even sound like a real word anymore and I never want to hear it again.

In case you didn’t watch the video, here’s the quick summary:

Gait is my favourite context to observe movement within. All joint motions our bodies can do happen while we walk. Unless they can’t 😉 This gives us a fabulous set of joint interactions to assess movement quality of.

The SIJ has it’s very own role in gait. Is yours performing that role based on its original instructions?

In gait, we’re interested primarily in the ability of the SIJ to compress and decompress at the appropriate times with each footstep to help us with shock absorption.

This is similar to how your foot goes through pronation and supination to give you that “bounce” in your step, but getting stuck in either position all the time can cause trouble.

Let’s move into how to self-assess your SIJ as your pelvis moves in three dimensions..

A Comprehensive Gait-Centric SI Joint Self-Assesssment in Less Than 8 Mins

AKA: The SIJ self-assessment a 10-year-old can follow along with (I hope…)

Here’s the second video clip from my Troubleshooting the SIJ (part 1) session: Dynamic assessments of SIJ compression and decompression in gait.

Here’s a quick recap of what is happening at the SI joint space during pelvis motion:

You should now have a better idea about:

  1. Which pelvis motions are flagging up your SIJ stuff
  2. Whether its a compression or decompression
  3. In which planes of motion it’s happening

So what did you discover? Are you like me: Compression in two planes, and decompression in the other? Compression in all three planes? Decompression causing most of your problems?

Now you know more about your SIJ than most therapists will be able to tell you, beyond, “Your piriformis and hip flexors are tight”. Can you see why this isn’t enough information to change the movement habit keeping you stuck as you are?

So… Now you have your data. What do you do with it?

4 Steps to SIJ Relief

A few important notes.

First, there is no one-size fits all approach. I don’t think its wise or responsible to advise on what exactly to do in a blog post, so I’m not going to 😉

Second, this is only ONE perspective. If it resonates with you and feels useful, that’s great.

In the full 90 minute Movement Deep Dive session I shared 5 exercises to try out. Their intention is simply to help you explore and reclaim the triplanar movements your pelvis might be missing, and then integrate these motions into two lunge-y, gaity-y exercises.

The all important pubis/xyphoid stack

The reason I hesitate to share the specific exercises here is not because I’m a selfish jerk…

anatomy in motion

To fully appreciate them, a fundamental understanding of the body’s movement mechanics through the gait cycle is key. This is why I like folks to go through my Liberated Body Workshop FIRST before attending my Movement Deep Dives sessions. Otherwise, the exercises will have no context, and you won’t get anything useful from them other than a face workshop from making confused faces.

But I can provide a thought process to get you started with right now.

STEP 1: Understand in which planes of motion your pelvis has movement restrictions or discomfort: Sagittal, frontal, or transverse (we already did that).

STEP 2: Note whether or not each of those motions correspond with compression or decompression of the SIJ (we already did that, too).

STEP 3: Experiment with exercises to give your pelvis, as a whole, the experiences of movement, compression, and decompression it is missing in ways that feel safe and comfortable.

For example: Are you missing the ability to posterior tilt your pelvis and could this be why the anterior tilt feels compressive? Explore some posterior tilt exercises and see what happens.

Experiment with different body positions. Supine? Prone? Standing? Handstanding?? (just kidding.. kinda).

The HOW is even more important than the WHAT. This means moving slowly, paying attention to details, and valuing quality of movement, such as:

  • Is the issue because you’re deviating from the plane of motion you’re trying to move within? For example: You’re trying to rotate your pelvis, but instead you’re deviating into an anterior tilt, compressing your SIJ. Could finding a way to make that movement more pure, clean, and honest be the solution?
  • Is the issue that you think you’re moving your pelvis, but you’re actually moving something else, like your spine, or ribcage, in an attempt to move your pelvis?
  • Are you doing the right movements the wrong way? Too intense. Too fast. Too little awareness. Too many reps. Too big. Too small… These are things it helps to have an outside eye with.

STEP 4: Integrate these missing pelvis motions with the rest of the body, the way we should see it in gait, so that the body learns to walk-IN the new movement options, not walk it off.

Show your body how these movements fit back in with your original instructions. Otherwise it’s just another novel experience.

Want MORE?

The clips from this blog post are from Troubleshooting the SIJ PART 1. But… There are two more parts, and I’ve compliled all three together into a little workshop for you: Troubleshooting the SI Joint

PART 1: What is the SI Joint? What movements of the pelvis create SIJ compression and decompression? How can we assess this? And a movement exploration to bring awareness to our pelvis motion and restore all movement possibilities that should be available to it (the topic of this blog post).

PART 2: What lower body influences could be contributing to SIJ crankiness? How do movements of the feet, legs, and hips impact on how our SIJ feels?

PART 3: What upper body influences could be related to how your SIJ feels? How do movements above from the spine and ribcage play into how our SIJ feels, in terms of com back. Stipulation: You have to write me a 500 word essay about your experience 😉

I hope you enjoy this guided exploratory series of movement sessions to get to know your pelvis and SI joint better 🙂

If you are an anatomy nerd/movement professional, and want to learn more about gait mechanics, check out Gary Ward’s closed chain biomechanics of the lower limb online course. SO good!

Conclusions?

This is certainly not the definitive guide to SIJ mastery, simply one perspective for understanding what’s up with YOUR SI joint, through the lens of gait mechanics.

Knowledge is power. You deserve better than a generic, glute squeezing, lacrosse-ball-sitting approach. You deserve to understand your body mechanics to make an informed choice.

Decompression isn’t always the answer. Sometimes our symptoms are due to decompression, and we won’t know until we assesss! Could you be compressed in one plane, but decompressed in another? Again, knowledge is power! Before chooseing an intervention, know your specific intent based on your body’s true demands.

This is an investigation of YOU, by you, for you. This is the creed of the DIY Movement Detective. No one can do your work for you, but you don’t need to do it all alone. There are folks like me interested in helping you figure your body’s shit out. I don’t want to tell you what you should do, only to help you think more critically, and give you more avenues to explore so you can find your own answers.

Seek professional help when you’re stuck. Massage, physio, acupuncture, movement coaching. If you have a structural/tissue restriction, or your nervous system is a little too triggered to feel safe enough to do any movement exploration, I strongly recommend finding a practitioner you trust to help you out. Even DIYers like me need a little guidance and support sometimes 😉

What did you discover about your SIJ?

I’d love to hear if you discovered anything new (or remembered something old) through this exploration. Was this useful? Is there anything that you want more clarity on? Shoot me an email or leave a comment on this blog post and let’s chat 🙂

So You Finally Embraced Foot Pronation, But Are You Doing it Wrong?

If I had only 15 minutes with someone to help them move and stand with more ease, but was not allowed to assess anything or ask about their injury history, I think the most impactful thing to do would be…

Teach them how to pronate their feet.

Pronation is not the devil, but the devil is in the details.

The Devil Is In the Details - Small Business Trends
I’m here about the pronation!

Pronation is an important motion the foot must be able to do as we walk. Contrary to what your orthotics person may have told you.

With each step, the foot gets just one chance to pronate. Could you missing out on the important benefits of this moment in time? (more about that below, read on!).

At some point in my work with most clients, I know I’ll do eventually take them through an exercise to show them how to access a healthy pronation, its just a matter of when.

I think that the world of therapy and movement professionals is opening up to the idea that pronation is a healthy movement to promote, with much thanks to the work of Gary Ward. Which is awesome.

However…

Just rolling your foot IN is not the same as pronation.

Do you know the difference?

Eversion (rolling onto the inside of your foot… I know, it seems like it should be called INversion, just deal with the counterintuitive language), is the frontal plane component of pronation, not the whole shebang.

My intention with this blog post is to highlight the diffrences between pronation and eversion of the foot, so that you can liberate your feet and wake up their muscles instead of living with a problematic chunk at the end of your leg.

So before you read any further, stop what you’re doing (unless you’re saving your baby from being eaten by a dog or something) and follow along with the video below. Let’s see how well your feet move. Are you just everting, or are you actually pronating?

The clip is from day 2 of my Liberated Body workshop: Foot mechanics day, in which we explore healthy pronation and supination of the foot.

In fact, embracing pronation is often the biggest take-away for my students. One said: “I was convinced that pronation was a horrible thing until this class!

Pronation is a tri-planar movement

Eversion describes only the frontal plane aspect of pronation

The main difference between pronation and eversion, in super simple terms (because my brain needs things to be simple):

Do you roll inwards on your foot, dump your knee wayyy inside of your big toe, and lose contact with the 5th metatarsal head on the floor? That’s eversion of the whole foot, not pronation.

Check out these images:

ankle inversion eversion foot | b-reddy.org
Accurately labelled. Notice the loss of 5th met contact in the eversion photo, and likewise, the loss of 1st met contact in the inversion photo. No tripod, no pronation.
BSMSanatomy on Twitter: "Foot pronation/supination.Pron++=flat  feet,Sup++=high arches.Its midtarsal jt mvt vs in/eversion=SubTjt  #m204anatomy… "
Yes, these are also labelled accurately: Notice how the calcaneus (heel bone) is rolling into eversion, but it appears that the whole foot tripod is still in contact with the ground. Got tripod? That’s a pronation.
Improving Turnout for Irish Dance - Part 2: Foot Alignment
Notice how the labels in brackets underneath that say pronation and supination are not accurate, because the foot is clearly rolling off the floor, losing tripod contact.

Are you doing the right thing the wrong way?

As with anything, attention to nuance is the key for success. We could be doing the “right” thing the wrong way,

Like when I first tried a low carb, high fat diet in 2013ish because that’s what the whole internet was doing… No one told me how easy it was to eat 12483275939 calories of fat a day and gain weight on a “fat-loss” diet. Oops.

Could you be thinking you’re pronating, but just smashing the shit out of your first met by dumping all your weight onto it, with no muscles managing the situation?

Here’s one more nuanced pronation “DO” and “DON’T” that I hope you picked up from my video: We DO want the knee to go slightly inward to access foot pronation, but we DON’T want the knee to dump inward so far it generates eversion.

Check out this video by Gary Ward (which he created to illustrate the concept from his book What the Foot, that knee over second toe is not a thing we should get dogmatically locked into because it limits foot movement in gait):

Here’s your pronation vs. eversion check-list for success:

Eversion:

  • No articulation between foot bones
  • Foot “log-rolls” inward as one chunk
  • Loss of tripod (5th metatarsal head lifts from floor)
  • No change in muscles length or experience loading/stretching under foot
  • Joints remain in same position, nothing decompresses/compresses

Pronation:

  • Articulation between the foot bones with each other and the ground
  • Tri-planar motion of the foot (sagittal, frontal, and transverse plane components- eversion is just the frontal plane component of pronation)
  • All three points of the tripod in contact with the floor
  • Muscles on the bottom and inside surfaces of foot, and back of the ankle load and lengthen
  • Joints on the bottom and inside surface of the foot open and decompress.

Here’s a slide from my Liberated Body workshop day 2 presentation that outlines what we’re looking for in healthy pronation and supination:

Why is pronation actually useful?

Just to clarify: PronatING is great. Being stuck in pronaTION, the noun, is not so great.

Pronation is like going to Wal-Mart- Get in, get what you need, and get out as quickly as possible.

Here are a three amazing things our body gets from healthy pronation (but does not get from rolling in, aka eversion):

Natural lengthening and loading of the muscles under the foot with each step: Got tight feet? Stretching not really helping? Rolling fascia out feels good, but not changing anything? Foot pronation is the movement that naturally allows the muscles under your foot to lengthen with each step. Got plantar fasciitis? Letting your feet pronate could be a game changer for you.

Extensor chain (dem glutes) load: Looking for more ease and power with each stride? Or to explode up from a squat position? Or land from a jump with more control? At the same moment in time that we pronate our foot in gait, the entire extensor chain of the lower body loads up. Calves load to generate plantarflexion, distal quads load to generate knee extension, and proximal glutes and hamstrings load to generate hip extension. Want to jump better and run with more ease? Make sure your feet can pronate well.

Free your neck and jaw: Got jaw tension, TMJ issues, and a stiff neck? At the same moment in time that your foot pronates in gait your jaw and cervical spine decompress. Could lack of pronation be one piece of your cranky neck puzzle? I wrote a little thing/made a little video about this so you can self-asess this for yourself.

And more…

Conclusions?

Pronation and eversion (rolling in on the foot) are not the same. One is a useful experience for the whole body, the other just feels uncomfortable.

Eversion is just one component (frontal plane) of a healthy, three dimensional pronation.

Losing the foot tripod makes or breaks a pronation. And a tea towel might be your new best friend.

Pronation has important movement repercussions for the body, such as allowing us to mobilize our feet naturally with each step, helping us engage our glutes better, and even freeing our neck and jaw tension.

Wal-Mart sucks.

Want to learn more?

I think you’ll really love Wake Your Feet Up, an online course by Gary Ward that teaches foot mechanics in a way that even my simple brain can comprehend.

He designed this course for folks who want to learn more about their foot mechanics and explore exercises to give their tootsies back their full movement potential. This online course is appropriate for all humans with feet, not just movement and therapy professionals who can speak biomechanics.

Ok I realize this post makes me seem like a huge Gary Ward fan-girl. I kinda am. Deal with it. I think he was my dad in a past life.

That’s all for now, movemet pals. I’d love to hear if you discovered anything new about your feet: Are you pronating well, or just everting? And if you can get your feet pronating well, what does it feel like for your feet, and the rest of your body?

Leave a comment, or shoot me an email, and let me know 🙂

Feeling Stuck in Your Exercise Routine? Here’s How to “Audit” Your Movement Practice

Do you have one of more of these problems with your current exercise routine?

  • You feel generally stuck in your exercise routine.
  • You don’t know what exercises to do for your goal so you default to the same shit even though you don’t particuarly love it.
  • You don’t really know what your goals are or should be so you’re just going through the motions
  • You’re just going through the motions but the spark, joy, and fulfillment are gone.

I’ve been there, too, my friend. Many times.

If you said YES to any of the bullet points above, then I invite you to do a Movement Practice Audit.

In the 30 min video I’m going to introduce the MESH framework I used to audit my own movement practice, to strip away the useless garbage, keep what was working, and reconnect with my “why” that keeps me moving (because, “exercise is good” isn’t a good enough reason…)

Need to audit your own movement practice? Follow along with the video:


Want to listen while you’re on the move? Here’s an audio version:

What is the MESH framekwork?

Does your movement practice MESH for you? MESH helps you audit four key areas of your movement practice to see what works, and what needs to change.

What works for you right now is not fixed. Auditing yourself every 6 months to a year is a good way to check in and make sure your movement practice is still serving you.

M= Meaningful

“Why am I doing this?”

Does your movement practice support your highest values? Or are you just moving because someone told you exercise is a thing you should do. Let’s discover what makes movement actually meaningful for you.

E= Enjoyable

“Do I even like doing this?”

Life’s too short to spend time doing shit you hate. And if you don’t enjoy it, you’re not going to be able to do it in a way that is sustainable. If you hate jogging, why are you forcing youself to do it? Could you find something comparable, that meeds your needs, and that you actually like?

Also note that you can learn to like something if you can connect it to your highest values. You might not love something in the moment, but you can start to connect with how it makes you feel, or that you like the feeling of mastery you get, or you like what it enables you to do as a result.

S= Sustainable

“As my movement practice is now, could I do it for the rest of my life?”

If the naswer is no, it’s not sustainable. Not that your practice should stay the same for ever. Sustainability takes into consideration that you will evolve and your practice will change, and that you are not getting locked into one paradigm for movement.

Also consider Dr. Peter Attia’s Centennarian Olympics thought experiment: What do you want to be able to do if you were to live to be 100, and how are you gonig to train for those, like they are Olympic events. Don’t just hope for the best.

Like my favourite shirt says… Train For Life.

Amazing shirt is by Toronto company Screaming Monkey Apparel

H= Healthy

“Am I meeting my body’s demands?”

Healthy means so many things to so many people. I like think of health as an act of meeting our bodies current demands.

Is your nervous system sympathetic dominant? Health might mean meeting that demand.

Do you have joint movement restrictions that are keeping you stuck in pain and lethargy: Health might mean meating that demand.

And many other factors that I couln’t possibly cover in a video.

So how did you do on your audit?

Understanding the MESH framework is a great place to start. From here, we can go deeper.

The MESH audit is just one tool of many that I’ve been developing for the past 2 years, and I’ll be putting it out slowly in a series of videos like this one over the next several months.

I’m going to be putting together an in depth program called Physical Mastery in which I’ll be taking a group of folks through all the steps of my movement practice audit. Not sure when it will be a fully actualized thing, but the gears are in motion.

Physical Mastery is for anyone feeling stuck with their body, uninspired, energetically depleted, and not sure what to do to get out of the physical and mental funk.

The Physical Mastery program will help you to connect more deeply with your body by understanding, healing, and deepening your relationship with it. You’ll discover what’s holding you back from inhabiting your body with more ease and joy through a series of practical and conceptual exercises. The end result is to have all the tools you need to build a movement practice that inspires you, and makes you feel energized, resilient, and grounded to take on the world.

Sounds pretty good, right? I think I created this program because it’s exactly what I needed when I was going thourgh a quarter life crisis and needed to get myself out of the hole I was digging for my body and my life: Eating disorder, compulsive exerciser, multiple back injuries, trying to meet everyone’s expecatations and dismissing my own needs.

Sound like you? I’m looking for a group of “beta” participants to give the Physical Mastery Program a test drive!

If you are looking for clarity in your movement practice so you can feel more energized, connected with your life’s purpose, and in better relationship with your body, shoot me an email to get in touch and be one of the beta participants.